Paradise for 20 minutes (or not!) pt 1

Your best friend Claire throws a party. You, Claire, her friend Jenna, Maria, Sasha, and 5 other guys make a circle and play a game Claire made up. It's called 20 minutes in Paradise and is a lot like the game 11 Minutes in Heaven. The girls draw a number and whoever they draw is the guy you get. You get to go first. You reach into the baseball cap, move your hand around, and pull out a slip of paper. It says...