The Great Debate. HP vs Twilight.
This is for HP and Twilight fans who want to express themselves and their opinions. Each chapter will have a different topic. So...Let the Debate Begin!!!
Chapter 1
Rules.
A/N: I was looking for anti twilight and pro HP pics when I was reading some of the fans debates and most of the twilight fan's reasons were completely ridiculous on which one is a better book, etc. Let me note that NOT all of them were ridiculous but most were, especially the religious freaks:/ For one, their reasons were because of the name of the book, J.K. Rowling's name (like seriously wtf?! Her name has nothing to do with how great the book is) and other stupid crap like that. Before any of you twi-tards start freaking out on me about being biased and whatnot, let me explain myself.
Yes I am a HP fan but I have read twilight and the summaries of every chapter of every book on twilightlexicon so basically I know the important stuff. I watched all the movies so far too. I created this out of fun rivalry and because I actually would like to hear both sides of the story. I'm not gonna automatically flame you or have something against you for your love of twilight. Honestly I just want to hear your arguments, opinions and reasonings.
With every chapter I will be giving my opinions on the subject, so I will also be in the debate. However like I said above I'm open minded and I promise to be fair. With that being said let's move on to the rules.
~RULES~
1. Reply only with valid arguments and reasons. NO- "HP/Twilight is better because it just is." Put down supporting facts and reasons.
2. Make sure you have your facts straight! That is one thing that pissed me off about twilight fans who were making arguments and didn't even know what the hell they were talking about. The same goes for HP fans! If you start ranting about things that isn't even correct it only makes YOU look stupid and it's really annoying.
3. PLEASE try to be civil. If you start getting heated don't result to name calling. Take a breather and continue with your statement.
4. HAVE FUN and I don't mean being purposely obnoxious and pissing off the other fans by making fun of characters. But if you must crack jokes just don't take it too far.
5. Don't be a spoil sport. Nobody likes a sore loser! NO ONE! So don't go attacking people because you can't handle it. I'm pretty damn sure you're only going to get ganged up on so save yourself the humiliation and just stfu and keep it to yourself.
6. I know for a fact many of you will get cocky and cheeky but PLEASE don't go too far.
Ok so those are the rules, at least the ones I can think of at the moment but for safety measures if you know or get that feeling you shouldn't be saying/writing something then don't.
I hope to hear all of you fanatics debates and arguments.
Yes I am a HP fan but I have read twilight and the summaries of every chapter of every book on twilightlexicon so basically I know the important stuff. I watched all the movies so far too. I created this out of fun rivalry and because I actually would like to hear both sides of the story. I'm not gonna automatically flame you or have something against you for your love of twilight. Honestly I just want to hear your arguments, opinions and reasonings.
With every chapter I will be giving my opinions on the subject, so I will also be in the debate. However like I said above I'm open minded and I promise to be fair. With that being said let's move on to the rules.
~RULES~
1. Reply only with valid arguments and reasons. NO- "HP/Twilight is better because it just is." Put down supporting facts and reasons.
2. Make sure you have your facts straight! That is one thing that pissed me off about twilight fans who were making arguments and didn't even know what the hell they were talking about. The same goes for HP fans! If you start ranting about things that isn't even correct it only makes YOU look stupid and it's really annoying.
3. PLEASE try to be civil. If you start getting heated don't result to name calling. Take a breather and continue with your statement.
4. HAVE FUN and I don't mean being purposely obnoxious and pissing off the other fans by making fun of characters. But if you must crack jokes just don't take it too far.
5. Don't be a spoil sport. Nobody likes a sore loser! NO ONE! So don't go attacking people because you can't handle it. I'm pretty damn sure you're only going to get ganged up on so save yourself the humiliation and just stfu and keep it to yourself.
6. I know for a fact many of you will get cocky and cheeky but PLEASE don't go too far.
Ok so those are the rules, at least the ones I can think of at the moment but for safety measures if you know or get that feeling you shouldn't be saying/writing something then don't.
I hope to hear all of you fanatics debates and arguments.



10 Comments
hehe i have been planning out one of these in my mind ever since that question 'describe HP fans'
MWAHAHAHAHAA EVERYONE KNOWS HP ROX THE WORLD!
DID TWIGHLIGHT HAVE HUGE PARTIES WHEN IT WAS PUBLISHED?
I DON'T THINK SO (not 100% sure tho...)
NOT ALL OVER THE WORLD ANYWAY..
IS THERE A TWIGHLIGHT WORLD AT UNIVERSAL STUDIOS?
NO!!!!!!!
ARE THE TWIGHLIGHT MOVIES ANYTHING LIKE THE BOOKS? DID THEY TRY SO HARD TO MAKE IT ACCURATE THAT THEY HAD TO SPLIT IT INTO TWO MOVIES?! DO--ran out of room.
hehe i was kindof gotten excited there...
can i have next chapter puppy eyes
?!? pleeeeese??!
I will add something to it that will make you shout YESSSS FINALLY!!!!!
I'm totally serious! ;D
oops wait nevermind...i thought your username was someone elses...
anyway i still have a relly well thought out arguement!! I will do the gr8est chapter XD
lol. I love your enthusiasm=] Um I would let you do the next chapter but I it's on single author. I don't know how this would work...any idea?
1) Harry Potter really hooks your attention, and pulls you in where you're so involved, that if feels real.
2) Harry goes to many places, such as the Burrow, Hogsmeade, Ministry, Forest of Dean ect. Whereabouts Bella goes to La Push, Forks, Italy.
3) The character's have touching backgrounds.
For example, Professor McGonagal, was supposed to be called Mrs. Urquart. Her husband died three years into the marriage.
Bella's mom, [No Backstory]
TOTALLY I KNOW HOW!!!
First of all, I'll message u my chapter, ok? and then u copy/paste it into a chapter titled HARRY POTTER ROX YOUR SOX OFF
:D i'm going 2 write it... then message u...
ok=) but I'm limited to internet so will be checking back in every other day or so.
I got your chapter and is putting it together but having a bit of trouble. I'll have it up hopefully today or tomorrow.
i WAY more prefer HP werewolves because well i sort of have a isck sense of humor when it comes to this stuff but i WAY more prefer HP werewolves because they DONT know that theyre brutally murdering some one, they change on full moons not at will like a shape shifter, and lastly because they dont look like big cute cuddlley wolves, instead, they look like something that actually WANTS to hurt you :) HP RULEZ!!!!! :D :D :D :D i could go one much longer....
well, I don't know much about twilight werewolves, but It seems they r just another thingamabob,
while Werewolves in HP are actually listed in the textbook 'Fantastic Beasts' or something, they r so dangerous...