Hogwarts 7 minutes in heaven

Ginny shakes the hat in your face, so you reach in and pull out...

• A piece of paper with chocolate smudges on it.
• A neatly folded piece of paper.
• A crumpled piece of parchment.
• A crisp, unused piece of parchment.
• A piece of paper that looks burnt.
• A piece of parchment with dirt smudges on it.