HP Character-Off (Twilight vs. Harry Potter)
This is my opinion and if you have a diffrent one please express it, but don't slander my own. Thank you.
-Skye
Ok here I want to talk about the "girls" in Harrys life. Not really. More like how people think Cho is some girly girl and and sl/ut who will cry if she doesn't get what she wants.
In the books she is sorta wimpy but she isn't a sl/ut, but in the books I like Ginny a WHOLE lot more than her.
Ginny is tough nuggets, smart, and got swag.
The way Ginnys character is wrote in the book is genius. Starts out as sorta of the shy, weird girl who giggles alot. And then BAM!
she kicks as.s
But in the movies, I like Cho better than Ginny. For the record, in the fifth movie, Cho is forced to sell out the DA, because of Umbridge.
In the books it's her idiot friend. So really in the movies she is cool. She isn't a sl/ut and is pretty nice, and quite.
I absolutely dislike Ginny in the movies. When you think about it, Ginny cheats on Dean.
In the sixth movie, she kisses Harry in the Room of Requirment, and she HASN'T BROKEN UP WITH DEAN YET!!!
HOLD UP!
So....what does that tell you?? AND in the seventh movie she is such an awkward flirt!!!
She goes to Harry with her dress zipped down to her as.s and is like, "zip me up.". Euww.
Plus she isn't wearing a bra, or either has chicken boobs.
Amen to George Weasly who breaks that little nonsense up.
My point is that in the books Ginny is a strong women who doesn't back down and is loyal.
In the movies, I feel like they didn't make Ginny as good as she could of been. They made her worse.
-Skye
In the books she is sorta wimpy but she isn't a sl/ut, but in the books I like Ginny a WHOLE lot more than her.
Ginny is tough nuggets, smart, and got swag.
The way Ginnys character is wrote in the book is genius. Starts out as sorta of the shy, weird girl who giggles alot. And then BAM!
she kicks as.s
But in the movies, I like Cho better than Ginny. For the record, in the fifth movie, Cho is forced to sell out the DA, because of Umbridge.
In the books it's her idiot friend. So really in the movies she is cool. She isn't a sl/ut and is pretty nice, and quite.
I absolutely dislike Ginny in the movies. When you think about it, Ginny cheats on Dean.
In the sixth movie, she kisses Harry in the Room of Requirment, and she HASN'T BROKEN UP WITH DEAN YET!!!
HOLD UP!
So....what does that tell you?? AND in the seventh movie she is such an awkward flirt!!!
She goes to Harry with her dress zipped down to her as.s and is like, "zip me up.". Euww.
Plus she isn't wearing a bra, or either has chicken boobs.
Amen to George Weasly who breaks that little nonsense up.
My point is that in the books Ginny is a strong women who doesn't back down and is loyal.
In the movies, I feel like they didn't make Ginny as good as she could of been. They made her worse.
-Skye
78 Comments
I didn't really care for either girl/woman, in the books or in the movies. I don't like their characters much. Though for a time I was convinced that Harry was going to marry Cho, because their rocky relationship was rather reminiscent of James and Lily (what we knew at the time anyway).
Yeah that's a good point and same!! I thought he would end up with Cho!
I agree. I liked Cho in the books, cause she wasn't the one who gave up the DA. But in the films, they presented her wrong. Although I do like Ginny in the books and films, although I think in the films she was presented a bit too... you know.
Hahaha ya know!! Yeah, I feel like the books are always better, not all the time but sometimes. And the way they presented Ginny in the movies was just bad
i like Ginny more in the books too
yea in the movie Ginny is kind of a slut
I can't stand Cho. She got around too much for my liking. Plus she defended her stupid friend Marietta even though she snitched them out because she was jealous of Hermione. Also in the movies she was dating Cedric but still kind of making googly eyes at Harry, at least thats what I saw. In the 6th movie it failed to mention whether or not Ginny was still with Dean when they kissed, just like they failed to even show Harry's interest in Ginny develope and progress. It just happened.
Yes they didn't make it clear if she was dating dean during the time she was kissing Harry, and I'm not a fan of Cho in the books but in the movies I like her.
I don't think she was making googly eyes to Harry. She felt bad because he asked her and she was already with Cedric.
I agree! With all of it!
I can't say I agree on all this, but this is pretty genius! Can you do like Ron vs. Draco? Or Hermione vs. Ginny?
Hahaha ok!! Like in what sense? Ecause Cho and Ginny had a theme where they were both dating Harry....
Scenes from both movies are clashing and I'm getting them mixed up so I gotta re-watch them. But in the movies or books I just don't like Cho...Ginny in the movies, I agree, they didn't do her character justice. @the pairing comment, I always thought...well hoped that Hermione and Harry would've ended up together. But when that was apparent it wasn't going to happen I knew it would be Ginny since she has similarities to Lily like the redhair and fiery personality.
Like for Ron and Draco, how they had to both sacrafice their lives for love ones(Ron for Harry and Hermione and everyone else. And Draco for his parents and himself because of Voldy D.) and who like had the better relationship or who was stronger for Ginny and Hermione.
Lol NICE!
Thanks brah!